Skip to content

Rent estimates

How accurate are Zillow and Redfin rent estimates?

Neither company publishes a nationwide error rate for its rent estimate on the pages we read. Zillow calls the Rent Zestimate a starting point and says its accuracy depends on local listing volume and public property data.

Checked on each company's own page on

What Zillow says

“It's intended to be a starting point in determining the potential monthly rental price for a specific property.”
  • The Rent Range is a confidence signal: Zillow says a wider range means less data or more volatility, and a smaller range means more information.
  • Accuracy depends on local listing volume and on how much property data an area makes public, Zillow says.
  • Zillow says it provides a Rent Zestimate for 125 million homes.
  • Zillow says there may be special features, location and market conditions its algorithms have not taken into account.

Source: What is a Rent Zestimate?(opens in a new tab)

What Redfin says

Redfin describes its Rental Estimate as an estimate of a home's fair market rental value, based on similar properties listed for rent or recently taken off the market. It says the estimate is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for the in-person expertise of a property manager or landlord. Redfin Rental Estimate(opens in a new tab)

Redfin does publish accuracy figures for its home-value estimate. Those are about sale prices, not rent, so they do not tell you how accurate a rent estimate is. About the Redfin Estimate(opens in a new tab)

Is there an official accuracy figure?

Not on these pages. Neither one publishes a current nationwide median-error percentage for rent. Older figures from 2011 to 2013 circulate online; we do not repeat them, because they are not current and we could not tie them to either company's present model.

How Honestkey's rent analysis uses more than one source

The report compares your rent with nearby listings, Zillow's rent index for your ZIP code, Redfin market data, Census median rents and HUD Fair Market Rents. It uses Zillow's rent index, not the Rent Zestimate. A source with no data for your address is left out of the report rather than filled in, and the report lists the sources it used.

A standalone report is $4.99, or $11.99 for 3 and $34.99 for 10. A rent analysis for your lease is included in the $19.99 lease review.

Run a rent analysis. This is not legal advice and not an appraisal. Honestkey is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.

Your questions, answered.

Something else? Contact our team

How accurate is the Zillow Rent Zestimate?

Zillow's explanation page does not publish a current nationwide error percentage for the Rent Zestimate. It says the estimate is intended to be a starting point, and that its accuracy depends on how many rental listings there are in an area and how much public property data is available.

What is the Rent Range?

Zillow shows a high and a low estimate around the Rent Zestimate. Zillow says a wider range indicates less data or more volatility, and a smaller range means it has lots of information behind the estimate. It works as a confidence signal.

Should I rely on one estimate?

No. Zillow itself encourages more research, such as talking to local agents or property managers and comparing nearby rentals. Compare several sources and recent listings near you before you treat any one number as the rent.

Read your lease before you sign it.

Upload it now and see your first red flags in the free preview.

Check my lease free